We craft innovative and tailored solutions with one goal in mind – the resolution of tax claims in the most cost-effective manner.
How We Can Help
The Tax Controversy Group focuses on resolving tax disputes involving the Internal Revenue Service and state taxing agencies preferably through an administrative proceeding, but when necessary, as a federal or state civil tax litigation matter.
Most tax controversies arise when the IRS or state taxing agency determines that there is an understatement of tax reported on a filed tax return or because of the taxpayer’s failure to file a return. These tax disputes may involve an individual, business (whether for-profit or not-for-profit), trust, or estate and can relate to any form of taxation – income tax, employment tax, sales or use tax, excise taxes, and property taxes. If unable to dispute the tax claim(s), we aggressively represent our clients before the collection division of the taxing agency to negotiate and compromise the tax claims, reduce penalties, or arrange for a payment plan.
Master Tax Technicians
The Tax Controversy Group focuses on representing tax clients and navigating administrative proceedings before the IRS Examination, Appeals and Collection Divisions of the IRS and state tax agencies to produce exceptional results. Our Tax Controversy attorneys are valued for their judgment, common sense, and depth of experience as well as their trial, negotiation, procedural, and tactical skills in resolving complicated tax disputes. We specialize in providing expertise regarding substantive tax laws, dealing with Revenue Agents, formulating audit defense strategies, and pursuing administrative appeals.
Experienced Tax Litigation Attorneys
Our tax controversy attorneys and tax professionals include former IRS and taxing agency representatives who possess strong accounting backgrounds and advanced LLM degrees in taxation. We deploy our substantial knowledge and experience to effectively achieve a favorable outcome in each tax controversy case – whether that case involves an administrative tax audit, appeal, collection matter, criminal enforcement, or tax litigation.
When litigating tax disputes, the taxpayer has a choice of three different courts: the Tax Court, federal district court or the Court of Federal Claims. When deciding on the right forum, our tax litigation attorneys consider many factors including the willingness or ability to advance pay the tax, judicial precedents which make one forum more favorable than another, the need for a jury trial, exposure to new issues and an increased tax deficiency, the need for extensive discovery and burden of proof considerations. Thus, although litigation is usually the last option, if necessary, we can provide skillful representation in all court proceedings. – whether to challenge the underlying tax claim, inappropriate collection activity or recovering overpayments through refund litigation.
Most of our new client referrals are by “word of mouth” for one reason – we are aggressive and deliver amazing results. If you’re in the process of vetting tax controversy attorneys – look no further. You can count on us to communicate clearly, be fully transparent and employ effective strategies using a cost-benefit analysis while applying a complex-versus-simple approach. Schedule your free Tax Case Evaluation today!
Frequently asked questions
We Are Expert Tax Controversy Attorneys
Still have questions?
Talk to a former government tax attorney. Free, confidential, no obligation.
One must be careful how they categorize and treat their workers because if the IRS or the state disagrees with the characterization, the results can be financially devastating for the business (in addition to payment of the taxes and interest there are substantial penalties that are added for failure to deposit up to 15%, failure to file up to 25% and accuracy related up to 20%). While most workers are happy to have less taxes withheld and receive a greater amount of remuneration for the services they perform, they quickly have a change of heart when it comes to filing their own tax returns and discovering that they must pay self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes – combined percentage of 15.3 in 2022) in addition to their income tax. The worker then becomes disgruntles and files a Form SS-8 (https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fss8.pdf) with the IRS, which in turn triggers a payroll tax audit of your business. In addition, workers often file claims for unemployment, injury (mental and physical) or disability with the state which also trigger payroll tax audits.
To establish that the payee is an independent contractor and not an employee, the IRS applies a three (3) part test which incorporates 20 common law factors which focuses on the extent of control of payee by payor – behavioral control, financial control, and relationship control.
We can counsel you about the proper classification before a problem arises and certainly represent you in responding to a Form SS-8 inquiry from the IRS or similar examination by the state. If responded to properly, you can often avoid a full-blown payroll tax audit of your business (which can cover 3 or more years). If not, we can assist you to pass the three part test incorporating the 20 common law factors or seek Act Section 530 relief (https://www.irs.gov/government-entities/worker-reclassification-section-530-relief) if you cannot satisfy the IRS test.
If you are unable to immediately pay your tax debt, the taxpayer can set up a payment arrangement usually in the form of a monthly installment agreement. Under an Installment Agreement, the IRS charges a set-up fee (which is reduced if the monthly payments are made by direct debit) and the taxpayer makes monthly payments. Unfortunately, interest and the late payment penalty (at half the normal rate) continue to accrue during the installment period.
The taxpayer can obtain an Installment Agreement by calling the IRS at the toll-free number reflected on any collection notice, use the IRS Online Payment Agreement (OPA) tool, or file Form 9465, Installment Agreement Request. Below are the pros and cons of each method.
OPA Tool – if the taxpayer qualifies, this is an expedited process which takes less than 30 minutes (and is usually even quicker than calling the IRS). To qualify, the taxpayer must owe $50,000 or less (inclusive of tax, penalties, and accrued interest) and be compliant with all tax return filings (business taxpayers must owe $25,000 or less).
Form 9465 can be filed at any time but is most effective if filed along with a tax return reflecting a balance due. Typically, the IRS responds to this request within 30 days, although the taxpayer could and should make a monthly payment while waiting for a response. Although the taxpayer is encouraged to pay the highest amount possible (because of the ongoing accrual of interest and penalties), it is prudent to submit the minimum due but then pay the maximum that you can afford to pay – this way you don’t default the agreement down the road during a difficult month. If the taxpayer owes more than $50,000 or does not agree to make payment by direct debit or payroll deduction, the IRS requires the completion of Form 433-F, Collection Information Statement (Form 433-B, Collection Information Statement for Businesses, which owe more than $25,000) which solicits detailed financial information under penalty of perjury. Note that the IRS applies national standards in their allowance of living expenses in determining what the taxpayer can afford to pay each month.
Other types of payment arrangements include: (1) Short-Term Extensions to Pay (up to 120 days to full pay) – no set-up fee; (2) Hardship Extension – may include a request for abatement of late payment penalty; (3) Offer-In-Compromise – can take a year or more and requires a lump-sum payment; and (4) Currently Not Collectible Status – if taxpayer qualifies, collections Is temporarily suspended but IRS will automatically record a Notice of Federal Tax Lien if more than $10,000 is owed.
If the taxpayer cannot pay-off the entire amount within a reasonable period, they should consider bankruptcy, especially if they are saddled with other debt in addition to the tax debt.
The IRS is required to send documents and correspondence to a taxpayer’s “last known address.” Thus, the legal validity of a notice sent by the IRS depends on whether the document was sent to the taxpayer’s last known address. As a result, its is crucial that the IRS have your current mailing address on file. If the IRS fails to notify you of a proposed tax liability at your last known address, the tax claim may be abated in its entirely.
The last known address is usually the address reflected on the taxpayer’s last filed tax return UNLESS the taxpayer provides clear and concise written notification of a change in address. Recent case law has made it clear that to properly notify the IRS of a current address (which is different that the address which appears on the last filed tax return), the taxpayer must file Form 8822, Change of Address form.
YES. If you fail to voluntarily file a tax return when you are required to do so, the IRS will eventually file one for you – called a “Substitute for Return” or SFR Return. To do this the IRS will typically rely upon information from third party sources including payor statements such as Forms W-2 and Forms 1099. When the IRS proceeds in this manner, they do NOT offer the taxpayer any deductions or credits. As a result, the taxpayer’s tax liability is often much greater than it would be if the taxpayer filed a timely tax return. In addition to being saddled with an excessive tax liability, there are other negative consequences associated with an SRF return – including an open statute of limitations for additional assessments and the inability to discharge or eliminate the tax claim in bankruptcy.
There are several types of examinations conducted by the IRS and each involves a different set of procedures. For each type of exam, the taxpayer is notified by regular mail. It should be noted that roughly less than one-half of one percent of all individual income tax returns filed are examined by the IRS.
Of the returns examined, approximately 70 percent of the examinations are Correspondence Examinations which begins (and hopefully ends) with a computer-generated letter requesting additional information with respect to one of more items on the tax return which are being questioned. Once the taxpayer responds, the IRS examiner will either close the case, request additional information or proposed adjustments to the tax return.
For more complicated and fact intensive items questioned on a tax return, the IRS will conduct and Office Examination which is conducted by an IRS Tax Compliance Officer and can usually be resolved by the end of the first meeting – so it is important to be prepared to address the items in question.
For businesses, IRS examinations are often conducted as a Field Examination by a Revenue Agent which is better trained and skilled to handle more complicated business tax returns and related adjustments. Field exams can involve multiple visits and information document requests and therefore take months to complete.
If you receive a notice that the IRS is examining your tax return, you are highly encouraged to hire an IRS attorney to respond on your behalf. All too often, the taxpayer and/or his accountant tries to respond to an IRS examination and “digs the hole a lot deeper.”
The primary way in which the IRS selects tax returns to examine is by scoring each tax return filed – different criteria are considered depending upon the type of taxpayer and tax return filed. Certain items reflected on a tax return may cause the tax return to automatically score high – for example, a home office deduction or travel and entertainment expenses claimed in excess of a certain percentage of your adjusted gross income, etc. In addition, if items reported by third-party payors do not match the information reported on your tax return, your tax return will be selected.
Other less likely reasons your tax return may be selected for audit include (1) there is questionable tax treatment or position taken on the tax return, (2) based on information received by the IRS from other sources (individuals, newspapers, public record information, etc.) and (3) to study taxpayer market segment behavior.
If selected, the tax return is then manually reviewed for further action.
Tax controversy and litigation involves the practice of resolving individual, business, or estate tax disputes with federal, state, local and foreign taxing agencies with respect to income tax, estate and gift taxes, state sales and use taxes, property, employment, and excise taxes. These tax disputes can be both civil and criminal. Although most tax controversies are resolved administratively as a result of our significant relationships with local taxing agency personnel, our Tax Controversy Group attorneys have extensive trial experience litigating all types of tax disputes, if necessary.
- Pay the tax in full (if not disputed and able to do so)
- Dispute the tax (if you don’t agree with the amount owed)
- Enter into a voluntary Installment Agreement (if you can “full-pay” the tax, penalties, and accrued interest within a reasonable period)
- Submit an Offer-In-Compromise (if your unable to “full-pay” the tax, penalties, and accrued interest within a reasonable period, do not have other substantial non-tax debt and can offer the IRS an amount greater than they could collect from the liquidation value of your assets and the present value of your net disposable income)
- Seek Innocent Spouse Relief
- Enter into a Transmutation Agreement (if non-liable spouse in community property state)
- Seek Non-Collectible Status (if payment would result in a hardship)
- Wait for the Statute of Limitations for collections to expire (10 years or more)
- Initiate a Bankruptcy Case to eliminate or reduce the tax claims (if unable to “full-pay” the tax, penalties, and accrued interest within a reasonable period, you’re not a candidate for an Offer-In-compromise and/or you have substantial other non-tax debt or state tax debt)
Beginning in 2015, The State Department must deny a passport application or revoke an existing passport (except as necessary for return travel to the United States) for anyone certified by the IRS as having a “seriously delinquent tax debt.” A “seriously delinquent tax debt” is (1) an unpaid legally enforceable federal tax liability, (2) which has been assessed, (3) for more than $50,000, and (4) the IRS must have filed a Notice of Federal Tax Lien or issued a Notice of Levy upon the taxpayer’s assets.
A seriously delinquent tax debt excludes a tax liability being timely paid under the terms of an installment agreement or an offer-in-compromise or a tax liability which is the subject of a collection due process hearing or if there is an innocent spouse relief request pending. Other instances where the tax debt will be excluded include tax debt of a taxpayer in bankruptcy, or the tax debt which is in currently not collectible status due to hardship.
The IRS certification process is an automated identification system the result of which is then provided to the State Department. Once certified, the IRS will send Notice CP508C via regular mail notifying the taxpayer of the right to judicial review.
Thereafter, reversal of the certification is required when (1) the original certification is determined to be erroneous, (2) the tax debt is fully satisfied, or (3) the debt is no longer a seriously delinquent tax debt because it becomes excluded as described above. The taxpayer is again notified via regular mail with a Notice CP508R once the certification is reversed.
As one can imagine, once certified it becomes an administrative “nightmare” to obtain reversal so taxpayers with “seriously delinquent tax debt” should be proactive in resolving their tax claims.
Although there are several different types of Tax Attorneys, the Tax Workout Group is comprised of tax attorneys in the first and second group highlighted below:
- Controversy and Litigation Tax Attorneys represent taxpayers in tax audits and disputes before the IRS, state and local tax agencies, administrative appeals and in the state and federal courts. In addition, this type of tax attorney will often represent the taxpayer before the Collection Divisions of these taxing agencies.
- Bankruptcy Tax Attorneys possess expertise in IRS practice and procedure (particularly tax collection procedures) and the interrelationship between federal and state tax laws and the US Bankruptcy Code. In addition, they are EXPERTS in determining the timing and best type of bankruptcy filing to ensure the maximize discharge of all tax claims and disputing tax claims in the US Bankruptcy Court.
Other types of Tax Attorneys include:
- Transactional Tax Attorneys which specialize in entity structuring, mergers & acquisitions, and real estate transfers to maximize tax benefits.
- International Tax Attorneys which focus on the representation of clients with respect to US based multinational businesses, repatriation strategies and minimizing the tax impact of worldwide income from assets and income derived abroad.
- Estate Planning and Wealth Preservation Tax Attorneys specialize in estate, gift, and generation-skipping transfer tax planning in the context of business succession, charitable giving, and transfer of assets transactions.
- Corporate and Partnership Tax Attorneys provide creative tax advice in connection with the creation, reorganization, combination, and dissolution of these business entities navigating the complex and constantly changing tax laws.
- State and Local Tax Attorneys focus on state income, franchise, sales and use, property, employment and other state and local taxes.
- Oil, Gas and Energy Tax Attorneys specialize in tax issues involving the multitude of energy transactions.
- Tax-Exempt & Nonprofit Tax Attorneys which specialize in representing charities, foundations, schools and universities, cultural institutions, religious organizations, trade and professional associations and other non-profit groups.
You MAY qualify for an Offer in Compromise (OIC) in special circumstances, are facing an economic hardship or otherwise unable to full pay your taxes.
The IRS may approve an offer in compromise when the amount you offer the IRS represents the most they can expect to collect within a reasonable period (generally 60 months) via enforced collection considering your ability to pay the taxes, current and future income, reasonable living expenses and the net equity of your assets. To see if you qualify, take this prequalification test – https://irs.treasury.gov/oic_pre_qualifier.
I filed A Joint Tax Return With My Spouse And The IRS Claims That There Is A Deficiency – Can I Qualify For Innocent Spouse Relief?
A spouse who files a joint income tax return is subject to joint and several liability for any tax claims related to that tax return and either spouse can be held responsible for the entire amount due – income and self-employment taxes only. If it turns out that one spouse may be innocent of the actions taken by the other spouse, the innocent spouse may make a qualifying administrative “innocent spouse relief” request on the basis that joint and several liability is inequitable under 3 separate forms of relief (note that the first 2 forms of relief – Lack of Knowledge or Reason to Know and Separate Return Determination – require that the tax liability reported on the filed return be paid; if not, then requesting spouse can only seek Equitable Relief) :
A spouse who files a joint income tax return is subject to joint and several liability for any tax claims related to that tax return and either spouse can be held responsible for the entire amount due – income and self-employment taxes only. If it turns out that one spouse may be innocent of the actions taken by the other spouse, the innocent spouse may make a qualifying administrative “innocent spouse relief” request on the basis that joint and several liability is inequitable under 3 separate forms of relief (note that the first 2 forms of relief – Lack of Knowledge or Reason to Know and Separate Return Determination – require that the tax liability reported on the filed return be paid; if not, then requesting spouse can only seek Equitable Relief) :
- Lack of Knowledge or Reason to Know – this form of relief must be made within 2 years after the IRS commences collection activities, the requesting spouse must establish that he or she did not know and lacked reason to know of potential understatement and facts and circumstances indicate it would be inequitable to hold requesting spouse liable (facts and circumstances include examining the nature of the erroneous item, financial situation of couple, requesting spouse’s education and experience, whether requesting spouse had reason to question or challenge other spouse, etc.)
- Separate Return Determination –this form of relief must also be made within 2 years after the IRS commences collection activities and the requesting spouse must no longer be married, or separated, widowed, or have not lived together for the preceding 12 months.. In addition, at the time the joint income tax return was signed, the requesting spouse had no knowledge of the erroneous item – unless requesting spouse can prove domestic abuse or violence. If relief is granted here, there return is prepared on a married filing separate basis without the tax deficiency.
- Equitable Relief – this form of relief only applies if the other two forms of relief are not available and considering all the facts and circumstances, it would be inequitable to hold the requesting spouse liable for the underpayment or the deficiency.
In addition, the initial threshold requirements for the requesting spouse to establish for this form of relief include: (a) no assets were transferred between spouses fraudulently, (b) the requesting spouse did not knowingly participate in the filing of a fraudulent tax return, and (c) the erroneous item relates to the non-requesting spouse.
If satisfied, the IRS will make a streamlined determination and grant relief if: (1) requesting spouse is no longer married, (2) economic hardship would ensue to requesting spouse, and (3) requesting spouse did not know or have reason to know that nonrequesting spouse would not or could not pay the underpayment of tax reported on the joint return (unless nonrequesting spouse was abusive and controlled finances).
If requesting spouse cannot satisfy streamlined determination, relief may nonetheless still be available if the IRS determines it is still inequitable to requesting spouse considering marital status, economic hardship, knowledge, or reason to know, whether nonrequesting spouse is obligated to pay tax by agreement or divorce decree, whether requesting spouse somehow benefited from erroneous item, general compliance with tax laws and the requesting spouses mental or physical health.
Finally, note that if the IRS denies the requesting spouse’s administrative request, he or she may seek judicial review.