Tax Controversy

Criminal
Tax Defense

All Practice Areas

We are a full-scale virtual criminal tax-defense law firm – operating in a more effective and efficient manner resulting in substantial cost savings for our clients.

Our history of success is built upon a foundation of intense and thorough preparation, careful review and analysis of the facts in each case, and then skillful execution at every stage of the criminal case – from investigation to defense of the matter at trial on the merits, if necessary.

01

When it comes to your freedom, winning isn’t everything – it’s the only thing.

Hiring the right criminal tax attorney can make the difference between defeat and victory. A criminal attorney that practices in federal court is not enough because most criminal lawyers are not well versed in the income tax laws and the complicated rules that are contained in the Internal Revenue Code and the related Treasury Regulations. Our criminal tax defense lawyers possess a combination of extensive knowledge of the tax laws and experience conducting criminal tax case jury trials. We are the firm that Florida CPAs and Attorneys look to when their clients are facing criminal tax exposure.

02

We are the premier high-stakes white collar criminal tax defense firm in Florida.

Our lead criminal tax defense attorney is a former Department of Justice, Tax Division Trial Attorney and an Assistant United States Attorney who prosecuted and later defended numerous criminal cases throughout the United States. In addition, for five years, he served as the lead Asset Forfeiture attorney for the Orlando office of the United States Attorney. When your case affects your freedom, life-time achievements, and reputation, you need an experienced attorney. Being defended by a former Federal government prosecutor ensures that you have the best experience, training, and resources on your side. Our criminal tax defense team has had great success representing clients at every stage of the criminal tax process, including administrative investigations conducted by the IRS Criminal Investigation Division, a joint IRS-DOJ grand jury investigation, or an indictment and/or prosecution by the U.S. Attorneys Office. Each of our criminal tax attorneys possesses an LLM in taxation and/or are CPAs.

As the story goes, Al Capone was sitting in the U.S. District Court building in Chicago when he heard the Clerk of the Court call his case, “United States of America versus Alphonse Capone.” He quickly turned to his attorneys and said, “What kinda odds are those?” When confronted with the power of the government, this becomes the feeling of every criminal defendant – let us represent you and level the playing field.

Our Tax Bankruptcy Group

Our Tax Bankruptcy Group operates as part of a virtual tax law firm, offering our clients a positive remote experience that reduces the need for tedious face-to-face meetings, the shuffling of paperwork back and forth and the need to get together just to obtain handwritten signatures.

03

Criminal Tax Defense

Our firm’s white collar criminal tax defense firm focuses on civil and criminal tax matters, tax controversy matters and asset forfeiture matters, which often occur together.

Tax Avoidance

While the law permits tax avoidance, it severely condemns tax evasion. Oftentimes, the courts have erroneously treated these two concepts similarly. In fact, certain tax Code sections even reveal an inability to separate the two. We are skillful advocates at further clouding the thin line that often differentiates the two.

Framework

The Federal government has created a comprehensive statutory framework of criminal and civil penalties aimed at prohibiting and punishing anyone engaging in tax fraud to deter noncompliance with the filing and payment provisions of the Internal Revenue Code. Because criminal and civil sanctions for tax fraud are not mutually exclusive, oftentimes exposure to one could trigger the other. In fact, it is virtually inevitable that the IRS will pursue the civil fraud penalty (75% of the tax deficiency attributable to fraud) against a taxpayer who has been convicted of a felony tax charge. The Tax Attorneys at Tax Workout Group are well-equipped to defend against both phases – the criminal phase and the civil tax fraud phase.

Criminal Tax Defense Representation

We provide expert criminal tax defense representation against all offenses under the Internal Revenue Code and the Criminal Code.

  • Administrative and Grand Jury Investigations

  • Tax Related Offenses under the Internal Revenue Code

  • Tax-Bankruptcy Related Offenses under the Criminal Code

  • Cash Transaction Reporting Requirement Offenses

  • Tax Related Offenses under the Criminal Code

What Sets Us Apart?

Our virtual Tax Bankruptcy Group offers a seamless remote experience

Ready to discuss your situation?

Confidential consultation with former government tax attorneys. No obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Experts At Resolving Tax Disputes With Federal, State And Local Tax Authorities.

Still have questions?

Talk to a former government tax attorney. Free, confidential, no obligation.

Schedule a Free Evaluation

The failure to file federal income tax returns can potentially lead to a criminal investigation, indictment and conviction, if willful.  In addition, there can also be substantial civil monetary penalties associated with a failure to timely file and pay federal income taxes.  It is therefore important to become compliant and handle these situations very sensitively. The IRS has a voluntary disclosure procedure whereby you can notify the IRS of your failure to file returns without being exposed to criminal investigation and prosecution. If you haven’t filed returns for many years, it is advisable that you seek guidance from an attorney who specializes in federal tax law regarding the filing of delinquent returns.

The U.S. operates a voluntary compliance tax system. What this means is when filing season is around the corner, individuals are expected to voluntarily complete their forms accurately and on time. While fulfilling this obligation, many taxpayers will explore avenues that allow them to minimize tax liabilities. There are a couple of ways taxpayers accomplish this: through tax avoidance or tax evasion. The former is a legal method for lessening tax obligations. In contrast, the latter is an illegal scheme punishable under federal law.  Sometimes, there is a thin line between the two.

Tax avoidance is structuring your affairs so that you pay the least amount of tax due. Putting money in a 401(k) or taking advantage of a tax-deductible donation are perfectly legal methods of lowering a tax bill, as long as you follow the rules.

Tax evasion is another method for minimizing tax obligations. However, tax evasion is an illegal activity involving lying to the IRS or another taxing authority about the amount you owe. It can involve misrepresenting your income, purposefully inflating your deductions, not reporting all applicable business transactions or hiding money in untraceable accounts.

Tax Evasion vs Tax Avoidance: As mentioned above, sometimes there is a fine-line between planning to minimize taxes (legal tax avoidance) — and committing criminal tax fraud (illegal tax evasion), particularly when it comes to complex transactions and international and offshore tax planning, which are oftentimes dictated by the timing of certain events.

Internal Revenue Code Section 6050I requires anyone who receives more than $10,000 of cash during the course of his or her trade or business to file a Form 8300 with the IRS by the 15th day since the cash transaction. Failure to do so can result in steep civil penalties as well as criminal sanctions.

In addition to coin and currency of the United States and foreign countries, cash includes cashier’s checks, traveler’s checks, and money orders (note: cashier’s checks with a face value of more than $10,000 are reported to the IRS by financial institutions).  Cashier’s checks and other similar instruments are only included as cash if they are received in a designated reporting transaction or if the recipient knows that the instrument is being used to avoid reporting the transaction.  A designated reporting transaction is a retail sale of a consumer durable, collectible, or travel or entertainment activity. In addition, wire transfers are not considered cash for purposes of Form 8300 reporting.

The reporting requirement under Section 6050I cannot be avoided by breaking up a single transaction, because the requirement is triggered when there is a receipt of more than $10,000 in cash in a transaction or multiple related transactions. Related transactions include those conducted in a 24-hour period. Transactions occurring more than 24 hours apart may still be related transactions if the recipient knows or has reason to know that each transaction is connected to each other.

Form 8300 is intended to assist enforcement against illegal activities like money laundering, tax evasion, and drug dealing. It is relatively detailed and requires the payor’s taxpayer identification number, name, address, date of birth, and description of the transaction, among other things. In addition to Form 8300, recipients are required to provide payors with a written statement notifying the payor that the cash transaction is being reported to the IRS. If Form 8300 is used to voluntarily report a suspicious transaction that involves $10,000 or less of cash, no written statement is required to be provided to the payor.

A late or incomplete filing of Form 8300 can result in civil penalties. An unintentional failure to properly file Form 8300 can result in a penalty of $250 per return. The total amount imposed cannot exceed $3,000,000 per calendar year. The same penalty applies for a failure to furnish a written statement with details of the transaction to the payor.

The penalty for a late or incomplete filing due to intentional disregard is the greater of $25,000 or the amount of cash received in the transaction up to $100,000.

Criminal penalties can also be severe. If a person willfully files a Form 8300 with false material information, he or she may be fined up to $100,000 and/or imprisoned up to three years pursuant to IRC Section 7206(1).  A corporation that commits the same crime may be fined up to $500,000.

A willful failure to file, failure to timely file, or failure to make a complete and accurate filing is a felony under IRC Section 7203. A willful failure may result in a fine of up to $25,000 and/or imprisonment up to five years. A corporation that commits a willful failure may be fined $100,000. A willful failure can include structuring the transaction to avoid triggering the Section 6050I filing requirement. Structuring involves disguising a large transaction by breaking it up into multiple transactions of less than $10,000 and/or combining cash and non-cash payments.

Generally speaking, the IRS will usually conduct the initial stages of a criminal investigation without notifying the taxpayer that he/she is under investigation. However, oftentimes Taxpayers become aware of a criminal investigation through information from friends or colleagues who were contacted by the IRS Special Agents in charge of the investigation. Additionally, the IRS Special Agents may also attempt to make contact with the Taxpayer who is under investigation. In these cases, the Special Agents will identify themselves and inform the Taxpayer that he/she is under investigation.

Other telltale signs that you may be subject to an IRS criminal investigation include:

  1. An IRS agent abruptly stops pursuing you after he has been requesting you to pay your IRS tax debt, and now does not return your calls. The agent might be getting ready to refer your case to the CID to investigate previous or current tax evasion or crimes you may have committed within the collection process. (ie. making false statements, hiding income or assets).
  2. An IRS agent has been auditing you and now disappears for days or even weeks at a time. After a case is referred to the CID, both the Collection and Examination Divisions put things on “pause” because they do not want to jeopardize a successful criminal prosecution.
  3. Your bank informs you that your records have been summoned by the CID or subpoenaed by the U.S. Attorney’s Office.
  4. Your accountant is contacted by CID special agents, or has been subpoenaed to appear before a grand jury and told to bring your tax records.
  5. An agent is overly interested in certain sensitive transactions, or has requested copies significant amount of documents (not just asking to review your records).
  6. An agent asks questions about the intent of your transaction, rather than its form.
  7. A CID special agent contacts you by phone or shows up unannounced at your business and tries to elicit as much incriminating information from you as possible without the protection of counsel being present. This is a sure sign that you are under criminal investigation. Never speak to a CID special agent without legal representation.

The IRS has two separate methods of conducting an investigation: civil audit examinations and criminal investigations. Additionally, the IRS has a separate division in charge of collecting unpaid tax liabilities.

The IRS has civil audit examiners titled Tax Auditors or Revenue Agents who are charged with conducting civil audit examinations.  They are trained to detect potential fraud during an examination. The Internal Revenue Manual (IRM) instructs these employees to be aware of indicators of fraud such as substantial unexplained increases in net worth, concealment of records, and excessive deductions. The IRM lists additional items that serve as indicators of fraud. These may indicate that a more thorough search for fraud is warranted.

IRS Special Agents are the individuals charged with investigating criminal tax crimes. If the IRS decides that criminal investigation is warranted, a Special Agent of the Criminal Investigation Division is assigned for that purpose. Accordingly, any contact made by an IRS Special Agent generally connotes a criminal investigation.

Lastly, the IRS Collection Division employs Revenue Officers to collect unpaid tax liabilities. An increasing source of criminal investigations have been civil collection matters referred by Revenue Officers investigating and attempting to collect unpaid taxes. While the mere non-payment of taxes due and owing is not a crime, willful actions to evade the payment of taxes is a crime. Like Revenue Agents conducting civil examinations, Revenue Officers are instructed to be alert for evidence of fraud and make referrals if evidence of fraudulent conduct is uncovered during the collection investigation.

There are significant advantages being represented by a tax attorney rather than an accountant or CPA – most notably the attorney-client privilege.  Generally, statements made to your tax attorney cannot be revealed to the IRS or used as evidence. While there is a limited federal accountant-client privilege for civil matters, it does not apply if the IRS decides to bring a criminal tax case against you. If fraud is suspected, criminal tax investigators may try to contact your accountant or CPA who could eventually be forced to testify as a witness against you. Consequently, representation by an experienced tax attorney will carry with it a communication privilege that is much broader in scope as well as having an advocate by your side who is well versed in the nuances and complexities associated with a civil and criminal tax investigation.

The IRS has a voluntary disclosure or amnesty program that allows taxpayers to come forward and voluntarily correct an error on a filed return(s) such as unreported offshore income, assets, investments and accounts prior to any criminal investigation.  If accepted, the agreement typically results in a non-recommendation of criminal prosecution, as long as certain criteria are met and there is a good faith effort to pay the additional tax that is owed.

The IRS has specifically recognized a thorough list of indicators of fraud over the years, and its agents are trained to identify those indicators.  A general summary of the types of indicators or badges that it looks for includes:

  • Understatement of income (e.g., omissions of specific items or entire sources of income, failure to report substantial amounts of income received)
  • Fictitious or improper deductions (e.g., overstatement of deductions, personal items deducted as business expenses)
  • Accounting irregularities (e.g., two sets of books, false entries on documents)
  • Obstructive actions of the taxpayer (e.g., false statements, destruction of records, transfer of assets, failure to cooperate with the examiner, concealment of assets)
  • A consistent pattern over several years of underreporting taxable income
  • Implausible or inconsistent explanations of behavior
  • Engaging in illegal activities (e.g., drug dealing), or attempting to conceal illegal activities
  • Inadequate records
  • Dealing in cash and
  • Failure to file returns.

The IRS Whistleblower Program was established to award an individual who provides information to the IRS about the underreporting or underpayment of tax by a taxpayer.

In December 2006, Congress significantly improved the IRS Tax Whistleblower Program by requiring mandatory award payments to whistleblowers who provided specific and credible information to the IRS that substantially contributed to the determination and collection of tax.

The IRS whistleblower provisions allows the IRS to reward whistleblowers who provide information about claims involving tax evasion or fraud amounting to at least $2 million (in taxes, penalties and interest). If an individual rather than an entity commits the fraud, the fraudster must have an annual income in excess of $200,000. Conduct covered by the statute includes underreporting income, maintaining illegal offshore accounts, and abusing deductions.  Note that the statute covers smaller claims but the awards in those cases are discretionary.

To claim the award, the whistleblower must complete and submit IRS Form 211 to the government submitted under under penalty of perjury.

Although the IRS will determine the size of the whistleblower award, depending upon the nature of the information submitted, the IRS can award a payment of 15% to 30% of the amount that the IRS collects. If the IRS principally relied on other sources to collect the amounts owed, or if the whistleblower planned and initiated the tax fraud scheme, the award is up to 10% of the amount collected.

An award is available only if the IRS pursues the case.

The Bank Secrecy Act of 1970 authorizes the Department of Treasury to gather information that has “a high degree of usefulness in criminal, tax, or regulatory investigations or proceedings.” 31 U.S.C. § 5311 et seq. Pursuant to this authority, the Department of Treasury has issued regulations requiring each U.S. person “having a financial interest in, or signature or other authority over, a bank, securities or other financial account in a foreign country” to report the relationship to the IRS. 31 C.F.R. § 1010.350(a). If a foreign financial account has a balance exceeding $10,000 during the previous calendar year, the taxpayer must file a Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (“FBAR”) with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, which is a separate agency of the Department of Treasury. Taxpayers must also maintain foreign account records for five years after the due date of an FBAR. 31 C.F.R. § 1010.420.

Failing to comply with the FBAR reporting and recordkeeping requirements may result in civil and criminal penalties depending on the facts and circumstances. Non-willful violations may be subject to a maximum penalty of $10,000. 31 U.S.C. § 5321(a)(5)(B)(i). For willful violations, the maximum civil penalty is the greater of $100,000 or 50% of the balance in the account at the time of the violation. 31 U.S.C. § 5321(a)(5)(C).

The severity of an FBAR penalty depends on a taxpayer’s degree of willfulness. The term “willful” has not been clearly defined by statute. However, many federal courts have found that a taxpayer willfully violates 31 U.S. Code § 5314 when he or she knowingly or recklessly fails to file an FBAR. A taxpayer is reckless if he or she clearly should have known that there was a grave risk that the filing requirement was not being met and he or she could have easily found out for certain. The willfulness standard can also be satisfied by evidence of willful blindness, which occurs when a taxpayer deliberately avoids learning about his or her tax obligations. Some courts have imputed constructive knowledge of the FBAR filing requirement on taxpayers as they signed their tax returns under penalty of perjury. There have been and continue to be many lawsuits regarding willfulness. Below are summaries of some of the most notable FBAR cases to date.

Internal Revenue Code Section 6050I requires anyone who receives more than $10,000 of cash during the course of his or her trade or business to file a Form 8300 with the IRS by the 15th day since the cash transaction. Failure to do so can result in steep civil penalties as well as criminal sanctions.

In addition to coin and currency of the United States and foreign countries, cash includes cashier’s checks, traveler’s checks, and money orders (note: cashier’s checks with a face value of more than $10,000 are reported to the IRS by financial institutions).  Cashier’s checks and other similar instruments are only included as cash if they are received in a designated reporting transaction or if the recipient knows that the instrument is being used to avoid reporting the transaction.  A designated reporting transaction is a retail sale of a consumer durable, collectible, or travel or entertainment activity. In addition, wire transfers are not considered cash for purposes of Form 8300 reporting.

The reporting requirement under Section 6050I cannot be avoided by breaking up a single transaction, because the requirement is triggered when there is a receipt of more than $10,000 in cash in a transaction or multiple related transactions. Related transactions include those conducted in a 24-hour period. Transactions occurring more than 24 hours apart may still be related transactions if the recipient knows or has reason to know that each transaction is connected to each other.

Form 8300 is intended to assist enforcement against illegal activities like money laundering, tax evasion, and drug dealing. It is relatively detailed and requires the payor’s taxpayer identification number, name, address, date of birth, and description of the transaction, among other things. In addition to Form 8300, recipients are required to provide payors with a written statement notifying the payor that the cash transaction is being reported to the IRS. If Form 8300 is used to voluntarily report a suspicious transaction that involves $10,000 or less of cash, no written statement is required to be provided to the payor.

A late or incomplete filing of Form 8300 can result in civil penalties. An unintentional failure to properly file Form 8300 can result in a penalty of $250 per return. The total amount imposed cannot exceed $3,000,000 per calendar year. The same penalty applies for a failure to furnish a written statement with details of the transaction to the payor.

The penalty for a late or incomplete filing due to intentional disregard is the greater of $25,000 or the amount of cash received in the transaction up to $100,000.

Criminal penalties can also be severe. If a person willfully files a Form 8300 with false material information, he or she may be fined up to $100,000 and/or imprisoned up to three years pursuant to IRC Section 7206(1).  A corporation that commits the same crime may be fined up to $500,000.

A willful failure to file, failure to timely file, or failure to make a complete and accurate filing is a felony under IRC Section 7203. A willful failure may result in a fine of up to $25,000 and/or imprisonment up to five years. A corporation that commits a willful failure may be fined $100,000. A willful failure can include structuring the transaction to avoid triggering the Section 6050I filing requirement. Structuring involves disguising a large transaction by breaking it up into multiple transactions of less than $10,000 and/or combining cash and non-cash payments.

Trusted by clients nationwide

Google Rating
4.9
Google Reviews

This firm is excellent. I personally worked with Matt Sherman and his vast knowledge and experience are impeccable. He definitely put my mind at ease and can help with any level of tax issues. I cannot say enough of how much he has done for me and my family. Also, Mori assisted me before I spoke with him and she was also professional and kind and just exceptional. I will continue to do business with them and would highly recommend them, I searched for the best and definitely was not disappointed,

MK 8 momths ago

Great experience with Tax Workout Group! They were professional, helpful, and made the whole process easy and stress-free. Highly recommend!

Malinda Moyer 1 month ago

Look no further when needing help with your Taxes! Tax Workout Group is very responsive and attentive with each tax matter. 5 stars all the way!

Lane Tanner 1 month ago

The hardest part was admitting I was in over my head. J. David Tax Law never made that feel uncomfortable. They focused on what could be done and handled the details while I caught my breath. Progress felt slow at times, but it never stalled and that was on the states end, not theirs. Ryan was so nice to work with, I highly recommend him for your tax troubles.

Aurora Sterling 10 months ago

Exceptional service! Tax Workout Group went above and beyond to resolve my case promptly. I highly recommend their expertise. I'm incredibly impressed with the dedication of Tax Workout Group. They were instrumental in resolving my issue, and their commitment to customer satisfaction is commendable. The support I received from Tax Workout Group was outstanding. They made a potentially stressful situation manageable and delivered results beyond my expectations.

Brandon Mendenhall 1 year ago

By nature I'm quite skeptical, and a bit of a perfectionist, so really not an easy client to please. I'm here to tell you that I'm truly impressed with the way this firm handled my workload and personality. I needed to resolve both a tax compliance issue that involved crashed QuickBooks files, as well as an institutional lending resolution.

Ariel W. 2 months ago

U.S. Department of Justice — Tax Division

Newsroom · press releases relevant to criminal tax matters

Sentencing

Business Owner Sentenced to 30 Months for Employment Tax Fraud

Sentencing

Tax Preparer Charged in $4M Refund Fraud Scheme

Sentencing

Contractor Pleads Guilty to Hiding Income in Offshore Accounts