Tax Controversy

Why File a Protective Claim For Refund For Cannabis?

Some things in life are simply no-brainers, not only because the justification for doing them is so immediately obvious, but further, because the justification for not doing them is so obviously absent. The filing of “protective” claims for refund as a hedge against the draconian provisions that govern the federal taxation of cannabis, and particularly for marijuana, is one of those things properly placed at the top of the no-brainer list. Why? Read on.

Jonathan A. Mercer
Jonathan A. Mercer Former IRS Senior Trial Attorney
2 min read

01

There is a strong likelihood of a legislative, administrative, or judicial change in the federal taxation of cannabis (and of marijuana especially) within the next 2-5 years (probably closer to 2 than to 5), whether focused on IRC §280E, the Controlled Substances Act, the determination of Cost of Goods Sold (“COGS”), or otherwise.

02

The likelihood is small at best that any such change would be applicable to “closed” tax years (generally, tax years are “closed” 3 years after the due date for the filing of the tax return, which means that all tax years before 2017 are probably already closed, and depending upon when the 2017 return was filed, it would likely only be “open” until 9/15/21). As long as a tax year is “open”, it can be kept that way for a minimum of 2 years and a maximum of at least 6 years by the simple expedient of filing a claim for refund. That claim for refund is called “protective” (sometimes called “contingent”) because it preserves arguments of non-taxability in the event that the applicable taxing provisions change. Only issues raised in the claim for refund are preserved, and any or all of the preserved issues can be abandoned at any time. Some potential issues:

§280E constitutionality

Deductibility of separate business expenses

Accelerated depreciation

Allocation of expenses under Treas. Reg. §1.471

Components of COGS & application of §§263A & 471

Work in progress inventory

2014 & 2018 Farm Bill

R&D expenditures & credits

§199A (Qualified Business Deduction of 20% of income by eligible pass-through entities)

Deferral of capital gains until 2026 under §1400Z (Qualified Opportunity Zones)

Penalty issues

Etc.

03

The effective tax rate resulting from the applicable federal taxing provisions can exceed 90%, resulting in considerable dollars at stake that could be “protected” by a claim for refund.

04

The cost of doing a basic protective claim for refund is in the range of several thousand dollars, and a bit more depending upon the number and complexity of the issues raised. That cost pales in comparison to the possible refund that a protective claim for refund could produce.

YOUR NEXT STEP

See where you stand — schedule a consultation

A former government tax attorney reviews your situation and tells you, plainly, whether an Offer in Compromise is worth filing.